After an enduring emotionally gruelling, but nostalgically enjoyable, “Mad Men” DVD marathon. The Rocketship Supernova was inspired to revisit some relics from that bygone era of widespread repression and good-old fashioned male camaraderie.
Who was the Lady? (George Sidney, 1959) is a delightfully dated romp in the grand tradition of mid-century “battle of the sexes” farces. Its a quaintly offensive little time capsule, just begging to be rediscovered by the Eames-era obsessed masses. The plot is pure hokum, but like fine wine, vintage hokum gets better with age.
Tony Curtis plays David Wilson, a mild mannered scientist whose wife catches him in an amourous embrace with one of his students (she's foreign, that explains it!). Naturally, David's wife Ann (Janet Leigh), is more than a little bit peeved about the entire situation, and leaves in a fit of comedic furry. Fortunately for David, his free-wheeling best friend, and former wing man, Mike, a swinging TV writer, has the perfect scheme to get him out of his marital predicament.
Mike encourages David to pretend he is a secret agent for the FBI, in an effort to convince Dave's wife that the juicy kiss with a cumly coed was merely part of his patriotic duty to bring down a ring of buxom Russian spies with pleasantly loose morals. This being the era of cold-war irrationality, Ann falls for the rather dim-witted charade with full special-ed aplomb. But just when you think Dave is going to get away with a little lighthearted adultery, things get predictably complicated (can't a man just enjoy a little extra-marital hubba hubba?).
Enter a real FBI agent portrayed with straight-laced intensity by the great James Whitmore, a couple of loose “showbiz” types in the Marilyn Monroe mold, and GASP! - some legit, and very devious, Russian spies.
The entire film is a masterful exercise in finely-crafted stupidity - but gosh darn it, it sure is a lot of fun. Dino brings a lot of heart and chutzpah to his role as an oafish cad, and Tony Curtis makes a most lovable lying adulterer. You also won't want to miss Larry Storch's hilarious turn as an anal retentive Rusky interrogator. If you thought he was funny in “F-Troop: - prepare to thoroughly wet your pants.
George Sidney's efficient direction nicely compliments the subject matter, and their is some glorious black and white cinematography - shot on location in Manhattan (in all its 1950's glory). The climax in the flooded basement of the Empire State Building is guaranteed to elicit some hokey yucks.
Sure its politically incorrect, but once you get past the misogynistic undercurrents, Who was that Lady? is almost refreshing in comparison to today's rather limp relationship comedies. I guess the moral of the story is: Boys will be boys, and boys do some very dumb things for mostly illogical reasons, but they will always be just wily enough to outsmart their intellectually deficient wives - at least until G-Men and Soviets get involved!
Three turbo boosters (out of four)